BuzzFeed dubbed Squawk Box one of 20 Subscription Boxes People Actually Swear By. In addition to kind words, BuzzFeed bestowed this bird pun upon readers: "Squawk Box will make bird parents far and wide extremely popular with their feathery friend. These boxes are packed with toys and goodies and your bird will feel like they are in *parrotdise*."
Catherine from HelloSubscriptions.com reviewed Squawk Box's Little Birdie Box in November 2020 and said, "Kiwi (the Lovebird) and I love Squawk Box as it is great to discover new toys, and maybe new favorites. We really enjoyed the variety of texture, colors, and types of toys that we receive in every box."